Giselle Atlas

The Big Smoke Next Gen: Is Trump the Perfect Example of Democracy?

What does the next generation think of today’s issues? The Big Smoke Australia’s Next Gen program publishes Australian students mentored by TBS Australia writers.

Today? Giselle, age 11, thinks our reaction to a Trump Presidency is unreasonable.


StudentGiselle Atlas – 11 years old

Topic: Is the election of Donald Trump the perfect example of democracy?


I may only be eleven years old but I understand what democracy means and accepting the will of the people. In the recent American election, which appeared to me to be hard-fought and sometimes quite nasty, the person the “experts” said could not win did win.

There was a lot said about Donald Trump, some good and some bad. But I was intrigued by something I heard former Prime Minister Tony Abbott say, “People are not voting for a saint or even for a role model – they’re voting for a leader.” I have looked at the lives of other great people in American History. Most of the great leaders, it turns out, have flawed personalities. People such as President John F. Kennedy, Reverend Dr. Martin Luther King, and a man I have developed a great interest in (because of the musical), former Secretary of the Treasury, Alexander Hamilton. This was a man who changed America for the better; but, as a man, history tells us he was a womanizer and was flawed.

People can be flawed and do great things as well, in some ways it’s human nature, we cannot be perfect all the time. And, if we were perfect, we wouldn’t be human. What I did notice was many American people wanted a change, they wanted a shake up, they wanted things done differently. But apart from anything else, they wanted to be heard. They felt, quite deeply it appears, that the government and maybe even the President were no longer listening to them.

They wanted someone, anyone—and in this case it happens to be Trump who just might shake things up—someone who is not part of the norm.

This might be a good time to tell you that I am not here to make you love Donald Trump. I can assure you that I do not love Donald Trump. What I do love is the fact that he was elected to do things differently, to see outside the box, and in four years’ time, if the American people don’t like what they see, another election is held and the same people can get rid of him.

Also on The Big Smoke

Donald Trump is willing to be President for little or no money. It is a pleasant change to at least have a president who it appears cannot be bought.

In another development, fashion designers are calling for a boycott against Trump, saying that they will not dress his wife Melania and will not support anything that has an association with Donald and his family. This seems to me like discrimination, the very thing most people do not like about Donald Trump. His opponents appear to be holding him to a standard they could not possibly live up to themselves.

I am not old enough to remember a world before social media, obviously, but listening to adults talk, it sounds to me that as a society we were much less judgmental and gave people the benefit of the doubt before the Internet came along.

I saw an old video of Bill Gates (now the richest man and the most generous) and you would never have thought he would be anything. I saw one of Mark Zuckerberg, the inventor of Facebook, and there was no way you would have given him a chance.

The world is full to the brim with stories of men and women who so-called experts thought would amount to nothing and have certainly become something.

The people have elected Donald Trump for four years; if given a chance, we may just learn something about him that we did not know and certainly something we did not know about ourselves.

From the little I know about Democracy, it is times like these when it shows its greatest worth, and if one may steal and slightly change a quote from another former leader, Winston Churchill: “In four years we just may look back and say: This was democracy’s finest hour.”


This article is part of a series for The Big Smoke Next Gen in Australia.

The Big Smoke Next Gen is a program which matches professional and experienced writers, academics, and journalists with students who wish to write nonfiction articles and voice their opinions on what is shaping the nation.

For more information about our program at The Big Smoke, or to become a mentor, please contact us. The Big Smoke America will be launching its own Next Gen series later this year. 




Giselle Atlas

The Big Smoke Next Generation: Giselle is eleven years old and lives in Queensland, Australia. She is an avid reader of all sorts of books from The Fault in our Stars to Harry Potter and Sailor Moon. She has a wide collection of Pop! Vinyl figures. Her favorite subjects at school are English, music, and drama. Giselle is most happy when she is reading, singing, playing on her keyboard, watching movies or videos (especially Doctor Who), going to the theatre, and acting. Giselle is interested in becoming a Neurologist or Lawyer.

Related posts