Loretta Barnard

Tomayto/Tomahto: The Artistic Synergy of the Gershwins

Never has the term “include your brother” been used to greater effect than the Gershwins. George and Ira were titans together, minnows alone. Sadly, it was not to last.


In a compact little room tucked away a floor below the main hall of the Library of Congress in Washington, D.C., there is a piano and a typewriter. The piano belonged to George Gershwin (1898-1937), the typewriter to his brother Ira (1896-1983), one of the most successful songwriting teams in history. Even though each man worked with other people over the course of their lives, their fraternal and creative partnership was one of mutual respect and the highest level of professionalism.

Everyone knows a Gershwin song: “Someone to watch over me,” “The man I love,” “I’ll build a stairway to paradise,” “Embraceable you,” “I got rhythm,” “But not for me,” “Love is here to stay” – spot-on lyrics and unforgettable melodies. Many songs from musicals they wrote like “Strike up the band,” “Funny Face,” and “Let ’em eat cake” have become jazz and popular standards.

As well as a master of popular music, George Gershwin is also one of America’s finest composers of orchestral music, his “Rhapsody in Blue” is as sensational today as it was when it was first performed in 1924, the piano played by George himself. Critics didn’t know how to react to the syncopated rhythms within the symphonic form. Eager to pigeonhole music into a particular genre, this spectacular piece defied categorization. It wasn’t classical, it wasn’t jazz, it wasn’t popular, yet it was all three at once.

“Rhapsody in blue” was a groundbreaking piece of music, an icon of American culture and one of the most popular concert pieces in the entire classical/jazz repertoire. The plangent opening bluesy glissando from the clarinet is one of the most recognizable musical openings of all time.

His jazz-based improvisational approach coupled with his mastery of popular music and love of the classics resulted in another of George’s great works – the Concerto in F (1926). Commentator Peter Gutmann writes that with this remarkable piece, George Gershwin became “the first American to be able to approach classical music as part of a great continuum, and to regard pop not as cultural slumming but in a wholehearted embrace among equals.”

Here’s a scene from the 1951 film An American in Paris, featuring the third movement of the Concerto in F played by his friend, musician and actor Oscar Levant. If you don’t know what the musical term “allegro agitato” means, you sure will by the end of the clip.

While in Paris, George was inspired to write An American in Paris (1928), a work of striking originality incorporating car horns and fascinating rhythms (haha, get it?). Again it was an expert melding of jazz, blues, and classical elements, the result another extraordinarily innovative work.

George and Ira were born in New York at the end of the nineteenth century. George took to the piano like a duck to water and by age 15 was working as a professional pianist soon scoring a job as a “song-plugger” in Tin Pan Alley, which entailed playing new sheet music for a publishing house. The more people who heard the song, the more copies were sold.

All this hammering out tunes day-in-day-out helped George refine his playing and improvisational skills and sowed the seed for his own compositional forays. He had his first song published in 1916 and before long was involved in Broadway musicals. His song “Swanee” performed by Al Jolson brought him wider renown. Soon after, he wrote the score for the Broadway musical La, La Lucille. He was off and running.

Also on The Big Smoke

Meanwhile, Ira, the older of the two, had been writing lyrics under the pseudonym Arthur Francis but his success was limited. In the early 1920s, when George asked Ira to pen lyrics to his songs, Ira found his true voice. His lyrics were fresh, witty, sincere: “You like potato, I like potahto; you like tomayto, I like tomahto … Let’s call the whole thing off.” Or: “The way your smile just beams, the way you sing off key; The way you haunt my dreams; No, they can’t take that away from me.”

There’s no mistaking Ira’s lyrics. They’re inventive, fitting the melodies in sometimes unexpected ways, wonderful works of creativity and originality. Ira won a Pulitzer Prize for his lyrics (shared with George S Kaufman and Morrie Ryskind) for “Of thee I sing,” the first Pulitzer ever awarded for songwriting.

Together, the Gershwin brothers, with librettists DuBose and Dorothy Heywood, wrote the opera Porgy and Bess (1935), which became the first American opera performed at Milan’s famed La Scala opera house. It wasn’t without its critics from the establishment and from black audiences, but George’s music grabbed collective imaginations and songs from the opera, such as “Summertime” and “It ain’t necessarily so” have been performed by too many artists to even begin a list. Here’s Aretha:

George and Ira wrote scores for Hollywood musicals, among them Delicious (1931) and Shall We Dance (1937) with Fred Astaire and Ginger Rogers, which received an Oscar nomination for Best Music/Original Song. They were on top of the world, but in early 1937 George began to experience excruciating headaches. A few months later, he was dead from a brain tumor. He was only 38.

After George’s sudden tragic death, Ira went into a decline for a few years. Theirs was such a symbiotic partnership that Ira felt unable to collaborate with other composers. Fortunately, he returned to work around 1940, writing lyrics for Kurt Weill’s Lady in the dark. He later worked with composers Jerome Kern and Harry Warren among others. With Harold Arlen he wrote “The man that got away,” sung to perfection by Judy Garland in A Star is Born (1954), that film honored with another Oscar nomination for Best Music/Original Song.

As well as his own work – including compiling a collection of his work in the 1959 Lyrics on several occasions – Ira saw it as his responsibility to look after his brother’s estate and to safeguard the Gershwin legacy. Before his death in 1983 at the age of 86, he wrote copious notes and gave them, along with original manuscripts and other items relevant to the Gershwin brothers’ musical oeuvre, to the Library of Congress. If you’re in Washington, D.C., it’s really worth seeing that little room.

George and Ira Gershwin were siblings without rivalry. That… “’S wonderful!”




Loretta Barnard

Loretta Barnard is an Australian freelance writer and editor who, in a long career, has done almost everything possible in the book publishing industry. These days she actively pursues her love of music, literature and theatre, and is something of wannabe roving ambassador for the creative and performing arts.

Related posts